Theories of International Mobility and the Incorporation of Immigrants

Class 9: Migration Policy and Synthesis

John Palmer

Policy

Muddling Through

Charles E. Lindblom, The Science of "Muddling Through" Public Adm. Rev. 19, 79 (1959).

Root-Oriented Policy-Making

  • Identify and quantify all related values held by society
  • Analyze every possible policy choice with respect to these values
  • Select the set of choices that maximize the values

Branch-Oriented Policy-Making

  • Focus on immediate, narrow problem and ignore related values
  • Outline and compare limited alternatives and use past experience to their short-term consequences
  • Select based on limited values and expected outcomes
  • Repeat
  • Root Method: Rational-Comprehensive
  • Branch Method: Successive Limited Comparisons

Sites of Regulation

  • Legislative
  • Judicial
  • Administrative

  • International
  • National
  • Subnational

Making and Changing Policy

Palestinian Rights

Refugee Return

Humanitarian Aid

Restrictive Immigration Policies in Europe and the US

Massey & Pren (2012)

From Massey & Pren (2012)

From Massey & Pren (2012)

Policy Mismatches

Massey (2020)