Theories of International Mobility and the Incorporation of Immigrants

Class 3: Determinants of Migration II

John Palmer

Massey & Garcia España 1987

  • Where is gender in this?
  • What are the costs of migration?
  • Is enforcement considered empirically?
  • Would we see same results today?
  • What about macro level?
  • Does it matter how close the connections are?

Massey & Garcia España 1987

Massey & Garcia España 1987

Massey & Garcia España 1987

$$P=\frac{1}{1+e^{bx}}$$

Neoclassical Theory

Borjas (1999)

Earnings Function

$$\log w_0 = \mu_0 + \eta_0v$$
$$\log w_j = \mu_j + \eta_jv$$

New Economics of Labor Migration

Whereas owners of production inputs or commodities . . . can ordinarily ship them away . . . while themselves staying put, owners of labor must usually move along with their labor.

- Oded Stark & David E. Bloom, The New Economics of Labor Migration, American Economic Review (1985).

Furthermore, owners of labor have both feelings and independent wills.

- Oded Stark & David E. Bloom, The New Economics of Labor Migration, American Economic Review (1985).

Relative Deprivation

Stark & Taylor 1989

  • Do intragroup comparisons affect perception, incentives, evaluation, and behavior?

  • Village A family incomes: 20, 30, 40, 50, 60
  • Village B family incomes: 20, 60, 65, 70, 75, 80

Stark & Taylor 1989

    Person is relatively deprived of X when:
    • does not have X
    • sees another person as having X
    • wants X
    • sees it feasible to have X

Stark & Taylor 1989

Local Market Failures

Social Capital

Segmented Labor Market Theory

World Systems Theory

Massey & Espinoza (1997)

Massey & Espinoza (1997)


v.


Borjas (1989)

Massey & Espinoza (1997)


v.


Borjas (1999)

Massey & Espinoza (1997)


v.


Clark, Hatton, & Williamson (2007)

Data Sources